It is strongly my belief that Ryoko out of all the characters is most in love with Tenchi - and equally, in most interpretations of the series, Tenchi has a special preference for Ryoko.
The most difficult series to define in terms of his affections (at least from what I've seen so far) is the OVA, where his attentions are spread pretty much between Ayeka, Sasami and Ryoko for the most part. This may well be because he is pitched as younger - around fifteen - when he releases Ryoko from the cave. However, when Ryoko is kidnapped by Kagato and Tenchi realises for the first time that she was under Kagato's power when she did all the things she was shut in the cave for, he is determined to go and save her - a decision Ayeka cannot understand. More, he almost dies to do so - and if it had not been for the interference of Tsunami, he probably would have done, too. Even so, he still returns to Kagato's ship Souja and to Ryoko's aid.
Ryoko's OVA bond with Tenchi is in some ways the deepest rooted, since she has known him since he was a tiny baby and has watched him through astral body projections out of her cave since that time, also. When Tenchi is tiny, he reaches out fingers for her, as if he can see her watching. He isn't afraid, just curious. When his grandmother passes away, Ryoko attempts to comfort him with ghostly fingers. In fact, if anything does get in the way of Ryoko's rapport with Tenchi in this series (and maybe in others too!) it is her pride. When she is resurrected, she seems to turn on Tenchi as revenge against the man who shut her in there. (This vengeance theme also appears fleetingly in Tenchi in Tokyo, when Ryoko is determined to fight and beat the man who wounded her so badly). This encounter on the roof of (and all over) Tenchi's poor school is an unfortunate beginning for their friendship, since Tenchi starts off life thinking of her as a demon and being a little fearful of her/her temper. Despite that, however, Tenchi does have one psychic moment where Ryoko is concerned - maybe a suggestion of a far deeper bond than is ever really explained. When she is taken by Dr Clay into his ship, she calls out his name, and Tenchi is aware of it, even though he's all the way back at the Masaki house.
After the incident with Kagato, Ryoko becomes decidedly clingy, not even letting him go to the bathroom on his own. Her strong desire is to protect him from further harm - even though it is a sentiment of which Tenchi is not always appreciative!
In Tenchi Universe and the subsequent two films that connect to this timeline, Tenchi's preference for Ryoko is much more blatant and much stronger. In some respects, Ryoko is in love with him the moment that she first sees him, after he helps rescue her from the wreckage of Ryo Ohki. And yet, I think it is when he raises a stick to her in defence of Mihoshi that she really falls for him - because he is no longer running away...he is proving that he has courage and honour as well. From Tenchi's perspective, however, the affection between them does not really begin to be apparent until the Time and Space Adventures three parter, at the end of which they have a decidedly progressive moment. Throughout these three episodes, Ryoko appears fairly often as Tenchi's love interest, regardless of whose world it is. In Ayeka's world of traditional Kyoto, Ryoko is the demon at Roshomon that Tenchi must go and slay - yet when he arrives at his destination, it becomes clear that he not only knows Ryoko but is on friendly terms with her and - dare I say it- is having an affair with her. And yes, that's in Ayeka's world. We haven't even made it to her own yet!
In Mihoshi's world also, Ryoko is the widow (black widow?) next door, waiting to pounce on Tenchi and steal him away. In Sasami's world she is a student in the playground fighting for Tenchi's affections, and in Kiyone's, she is seated with Tenchi in the bar most of the time, drinking sake with him, Noboyuke and Kazuhito.
But it is the conversation at the close of her own world that really develops the bond between her and Tenchi. At first unwilling to relinquish what she sees as the perfect world for them to be together in, she realises after some moments alone that it will never be real between them if they stay in this world. As he tells her - "you never give me any choices!" and I think that resonates inside of her - it's her world, not his, and to really have someone's love you need to compromise (something she hasn't really learnt about before this).
When she returns to him and Washu,
it is to return to the real world, because she'd rather win his love
the real way, and sacrifice her own wishes to do so. Tenchi seems
tongue-tied and unable to express how he really feels at the end of
this episode, and even when he tries to explain that he didn't hate
travelling with her, Ryoko hushes him, in case it interferes with their
transfer back to the real world. However, when she grips his hand, he
doesn't push her away, but grips hers tighter and sends her a grin. At
the very end of the episode, when Ayeka thinks Ryoko is pushing herself
on Tenchi again, she is actually atop the shrine gateway, dreaming. It
is Tenchi who approaches Ryoko, and tosses her an apple.
There appears to be hidden symbolism in this gesture. That he gives her
an apple seems to mean more than just "here, have some food" (See
Ryoko's OTHER section for more about this!) It's not quite a
declaration of love (lol!) but it does mark a new understanding between
them. Maybe I'm reaching, but there has to be something more to it ^_^.
This episode is a watershed, because from hereon in their relationship is less pushy on Ryoko's side and more interested from Tenchi's. When Yagami is hijacked, Ryoko tells Tenchi to count on her and he tells her that he does. In that episode also, they take off after Yagami, leaving Ayeka and Sasami behind (out of sight, out of mind!). And of course, at the conclusion of the series, Ryoko almost gives her life helping Tenchi to get to Jurai. This is often cited, but what is not so often mentioned is the lingering look of regret Tenchi sends Ryoko when he leaves her side to do battle with Kagato. Ryoko has to practically order him to leave, since it seems pretty obvious he'd rather stay with her. Duty calls, and all that - even though he tells her he'd like to take a trip with her (see, there's that trip motif again!) he knows he has to do the right thing and avenge his grandfather's attack.
It's also worth mentioning that, after the battle with Kagato, Tenchi chooses not to stay on Jurai with Ayeka, even though he could quite easily do so. When he recounts everything at the close of No Need For A Conclusion, he gives us no information on Ryoko's fate, but it's clear he's wondering where she is and what's become of her. As he walks to get the bus for school, he hallucinates Ryo Ohki on a stone when he hears the mew of a cat, and then he thinks he sees Ryoko herself up ahead. Or is it a hallucination? Difficult to say, since Ryoko does descend at that point, stopping him dead and greeting him with a joyful hug. At other points in the series, when Ryoko has thrown herself at Tenchi, he has been less than enthusiastic about it. But this time he is plainly happy to see her, dropping his school bag and returning her hug with a grin of his own. (Whether he ever got to school that day is a mystery...honestly, I have my doubts!) Evidently, even when they are apart, his mind is on Ryoko and not on planet Jurai.
The movies touch on this theme also,
although in the interests of objectivity (who am I kidding?) there
isn't so much direct evidence in Tenchi Muyo In Love. I think Tenchi is
so concerned with saving his mother that he hasn't much time to worry
about Ryoko or Ayeka, in truth. It's said the film leads on from the
end of Universe (and anyone who hates that ending obviously just hates
the idea of Ryoko and Tenchi getting it together) but actually it seems
to backtrack in terms of the relationships between characters. The link
is very tenuous indeed (even to the point where Jurai magically
develops an Emperor that doesn't exist in the entirety of the Universe
series!). This being said, the only thing that I can settle on here for
Tenchi and Ryoko is the fact that she is the one who brings him out of
the other dimension, and refuses to set him down even for a minute
while she tries to find the memory gems to give to Ayeka. Equally, I
suppose, she throws herself into the fray and grabs him, preventing him
from being sucked into the dimension with his mother and father.
Perhaps the most interesting thing, though, is Washu's idea about how
they find Achika - that Tenchi can pick up his mother's brainwaves and
then Ryoko can teleport to that location. This suggests some kind of
telepathic bond between Ryoko and Tenchi (just as the brief suggestions
exist in the OVA and Tenchi in Tokyo). It's not conclusive, but I don't
see how else Ryoko would have known those coordinates. And she is a
telepath, so it's not impossible at all.
More conclusive, however, is the second film on this timeline, "Tenchi
Forever" or "Tenchi Muyo In Love II" (it gets called both). When Tenchi
disappears, Ryoko and Ayeka team up to find him, but it is Ryoko who
Tenchi hallucinates and draws when he is in Haruna's ghostly world.
Even though his memory of his previous life has been erased and
replaced with something Haruna wants him to believe, Ryoko's image
keeps cropping up there and Haruna is clearly threatened by it. When
Ryoko and Ayeka break into the alternative world, he says Ryoko's name
without any prompting, followed by "You're real!" In contrast, he
demands of Ayeka - "Who are you?".
From Ryoko's perspective, she is
determined to rescue Tenchi until she believes he wants to stay with
Haruna (although this breaks her heart). Like relinquishing her world
at the end of Time and Space Adventures III and her near sacrifice at
the close of the series itself, Ryoko's affection for Tenchi means that
she will help him get to whatever will make him happy...even if it
destroys her own hopes and dreams in the process. Although Tenchi never
definitively says to Ryoko "I love you", the evidence is all there that
he does. At the end of the film he tells her "you understand me" and "I
can count on you." It's almost like he knows she is coming for him -
and holds out his faith that she will.
There is also other evidence in this film that this has become more
than just a good friendship. When they are in the coffee shop, Ryoko's
frantic behaviour seems to penetrate his sub conscious, bringing on a
headache and leading him to have further hallucinations of the space
pirate. At the close of the film, Ayeka says that only Ryoko can reach
Tenchi, as if she has accepted that Tenchi's feelings for the pirate
are stronger than his feelings are for her. This she might possibly
have known even since the end of the television series - as he did not
choose to stay with her on Jurai like she asked him to. Washu
also states that scientific interference in the world is no longer
possible, but that the world is entirely constructed of emotion -
including the emotion Tenchi obviously has for Ryoko. Washu does state
that "his thoughts keep bringing him back here", referring to the real
world - and since those thoughts are of Ryoko, it stands to reason that
it's her (like in Manatsu No Eve, see below) that is breaking through
Haruna's false charms. This is the probable reason why only Ryoko can
go and get him back at the end.
Tenchi tells Haruna he has to paint what is 'in his heart and in his
head'. Quite clearly, Ryoko is in both - and Haruna feels threatened
enough by her imagined presence to destroy Tenchi's pictures of her
(something which Tenchi cannot understand). Tenchi also asks her to
change the curtains from pink to 'light blue', the same colour as
Ryoko's hair. This seems to distress Haruna also - because she tells
him that she's afraid she's going to lose him. She obviously also sees
the connection - that something in his mind is still pulling him back
to the real world. If you want to get really technical, you could see
the curtain switch as a choice in itself, since Haruna's hair ribbon is
pink, like the original curtains!
Although there is no conclusive
'decision' at the close, it doesn't take a genius to work out what the
audience are expected to think. (In fact, if you can't see it, you're
actively deluding yourself :S). At the end of the film, Tenchi says to
Ryoko, a little cryptically, that his painting is inspired by what he
feels, and that it's something that's in his heart. Since he painted
Ryoko in Haruna's world, that clearly indicates that it's her who is in
his heart. (Something which she clearly gets the meaning of - after
all, he does ask her in Haruna's world whether she came out of his
drawing, so she must know he's been drawing her!)
Moving on further from that, if there's still any need for convincing,
you just have to watch the closing titles. In sepia brown, as if
leading on from Tenchi's comments about things that he'd forgotten from
long ago but that were in his heart, there is a little chronicle of his
encounters with Ryoko from the Universe series. The montage goes pretty
much from his meeting her, through her near sacrifice, his battle on
Jurai (but surprisingly without showing Ayeka as the reason for him
being there), his parting from Ayeka (when she is in tears and refuses
to take his hand), his return to the Earth and then Ryoko's return to
him, ending in their hug. Also slipped in here is an image of Yosho and
his wife Itzuki and it struck me that Tenchi is merely following in
Yosho's footsteps - Yosho set aside his memories of Haruna (a Juraian
woman) to marry someone in his new world and begin his new life on
Earth. And Tenchi set aside his genetic bond with the Juraian throne
and his opportunity to become Emperor to return to his normal life (and
clearly, to choose Ryoko).
In this Tenchi-verse, then, you'd need to have been hit very hard on the head by a mallet not to realise that the conclusion is a Ryoko/Tenchi pairing, even if it's not said in as many words.
In Tenchi in Tokyo, Ryoko's
relationship with Tenchi is a lot more volatile - at least to begin
with. Sometimes she almost seems to scare him - when she asks him on
her 'date', she tells him "if you don't turn up, you know what will
happen!", and so he does turn up, as if afraid of some big violent
scene. Ryoko herself is a lot more brash and forceful in this series
anyway, so the chemistry between the two of them is slightly different.
However, despite all of that, this is the only time I've seen Tenchi
admit his feelings for Ryoko in words - "She's sure selfish and
unpredictable, yet somehow I'm attracted to her. She was kinda cute
tonight." This is further compounded by Sakuya's confrontation of him -
when he tries to deny that there is someone else 'waiting for him',
Sakuya accuses him of lying to her, and tells him she can tell when
he's not telling the truth. And yet, it is Ryoko who ends this one off
date, not Tenchi - as if she feels like the whole thing is getting out
of her control and that she has to pull back before she gets herself
further in than she can handle.
It's unclear what exactly sparks his change of heart in this series,
though her own bond with him is forged when she is lying unconscious in
a coma, after their very first meeting. Even though it is Tenchi who
has caused her such grievous harm and even though she was a monster
when they first met, Tenchi is constantly at her bedside and Ryoko
slowly falls for the man who is taking care of her like noone ever has
before. Equally, it is Tenchi's apparent betrayal of her with Sakuya
that drives her to leave the house and take up with Hotsuma...nursing
the bitter anger of a woman scorned. Ironically, then, the love contest
in this series is Ryoko vs Sakuya - NOT Ryoko vs Ayeka (despite their
constant sparring).
And yet, even here
Tenchi retains that strange psychic link with Ryoko. Maybe it's the
gems in this series, I'm not sure...but on two occasions he seems to
sense she's in trouble (firstly, when the house is attacked by Yugi and
Ryoko takes the kid on in "Eye of the Destroyer", the second time when
she's attacked by Yugi's fake Galaxy Police droids at the House of the
Eternal Pledge in "Drifting Away"). At both times he is with Sakuya,
yet his mind is called back to Ryoko - interesting, isn't it? And
especially on the second occasion, he is really not paying any
attention to Sakuya after the sudden flash - which is probably because
she's talking tripe :S. And though he
confesses to Sakuya that he loves her, it's Ryoko who he ends up up a
tree with at the end, talking about Yugi and about his relationship
with Sakuya. Ryoko refers to it as a 'fling' and Tenchi doesn't deny
it...or maybe he just knows that Sakuya was an illusion, while Ryoko -
even if she's not house trained - is very real. Not that it's
conclusive that, at the close of this series, you feel he will take up
with Ryoko now. I don't think it's that way at all, since the Ryoko of
this series has a lot more to learn about what being in love really
means (ie it's not just about 'having fun', but it is a lot deeper than
that and Tenchi would not be satisfied with something self centred and
on the surface). Just that it's the
beginning of a new understanding between them.
In many ways it's something of an epiphany for Ryoko - she decides at the end that it doesn't matter if Tenchi's with someone else, because her love for him will make her able to triumph. In the dub, it's a little bit ambiguous whether she means her love will make her triumph over Hotsuma or whether it means she's going to win Tenchi in the end. But in the subtitles it's a lot less vague - it says "It doesn't matter who Tenchi's with. The one who's going to win is me!". So she means that she'll get Tenchi in the end...and killing Hotsuma is just a means to that end (ie she's decided her love is stronger and less insecure and she's willing to fight for it as strongly as she's fighting for her life right now.)
Tenchi obviously feels
he has done something to hurt/betray Ryoko, because he is apologetic
and a little embarrassed when talking to her about the whole Sakuya
business. Equally, Ryoko has had something of an epiphany whilst with
Hotsuma - that her feelings for Tenchi are not dependant on his
feelings for her and what's more, she's more settled with them as they
are without even needing his constant support or attention. (I have
heard it said that Tenchi asks Yugi to bring Sakuya
back. I'm confused. Having watched all twenty six episodes, I've yet to
find that moment. In the episodes I watched, he confessed his love to
Sakuya, then left her to disappear, returning to Earth because he has
to save the planet.) It's also interesting to note at this point that,
when he is falling from the Crystal Castle (no She-Ra jokes!!), it is
Ryoko who is there to break his fall. Nothing new about that, is there?
In the final film (Manatsu No Eve), Tenchi's relationship with Ryoko is
also pretty clear. When Mayuka decides to take a bath with Daddy, it's
Ryoko that Tenchi tries to placate - "It's not how it looks!". Though
they spend a lot of this film in conflict, since Ryoko is both jealous
and suspicious of the too-sweet Mayuka, it is also Ryoko who goes with
Tenchi into Yuzuha's lair to try and rescue Sasami. There is underlying
symbolism here too - Yuzuha makes it clear earlier on in the film that
whoever you spend the Juraian summer festival of Startica with is
likely to prove your true love. Sasami says earlier in the film that
it's 'about the time' of Startica on Jurai, when all of this is taking
place. So, when Ryoko and Tenchi go into Yuzuha's lair and encounter
her possessed daughter and parodied Christmas celebration, they are
actually spending Startica together. Yuzuha even says that Ryoko is in
love with Tenchi - and Ryoko does not even bother to deny it, simply
telling him that there's no way she'll leave him there at Yuzuha's
mercy (injured or not!). In fact, in many ways it seems like Yuzuha's
behaviour with Mayuka is intended to cause a rift between Ryoko and
Tenchi, since Yuzuha is happy when they are fighting and cross when
they seem to repair their bonds. Although Yuzuha's toys greet Tenchi
with a welcome to the "prince of
Jurai and his devil princess and space pirate", it's not quite
certain what the 'devil princess' is referring to. Is it Ayeka, back in
the ordinary world? Or Sasami, trapped in the trunk of the tree? Or
some kind of joke on Ryoko's 'demon' status in the OVA series? The subtitling is less ambiguous - the mocking bear refers to Ryoko and Tenchi as the 'Prince of Jurai and the former space pirate and demon princess' and then talks about them BOTH being welcome in Yuzuha's world. So the term demon princess is meant for Ryoko - which I find interesting!!
As the
canon for this film seems to be a mishmash of OVA (Yosho's tree) and
Universe (presence of Kiyone), everything is possible ^_^. It's also
worth noting that although even Yosho/Kazuhito and his sword of Jurai
can't break Yuzuha's spell in Tenchi's bedroom, Ryoko appears to do so
just by teleporting in there and screaming his name. Since it is her
presence over the shrine steps that also breaks the earlier trance, it
suggests that something deeper inside Tenchi is overriding the hypnosis
to let Mayuka seduce him - could it be genuine affection for Ryoko??
The most telling moments in the film
come in their most violent quarrel ever - when Tenchi raises his hand
and slaps Ryoko across the cheek. The unforgiveable action sends Ryoko
disappearing into the night, feeling unwanted and unloved, and gives
Tenchi agonies of guilt as he hunts her down. Finally, when he does
find her, Ryoko comes very close to expressing her true fears for him,
and there's even a nice little cuddle on the roof. (Well, it must be
true love, if he's willing to climb up onto the roof for her!) Tenchi also, significantly says something that he should have known Ryoko wouldn't bully Mayuka - although this only appears on the subtitling so presumably the original Japanese dub. It does suggest some deeper understanding of Ryoko, however.
Later on in the film she breaks down even further, so afraid for
Tenchi's safety after Mayuka's attempted abduction that she clings onto
him, bursting into tears (much to his complete confusion!).
CONCLUSION
Tenchi loves Ryoko!
Okay, so maybe he doesn't 100% love her in every single episode of
every series. Wouldn't that be boring, though, if he did? But he does
grow to love her in all of them, whether as a very dear friend or as
something more significant. And what is much more important is Ryoko's
feelings for Tenchi - constant and unchanging, despite all the abuse
thrown her way. She's called a demon, a monster and a freeze dried
mummy. He tells her he hates her when she ruins his mother's dress and
she's slapped round the face for trying to protect him. She's forced to
witness him kissing another woman after she'd given him her trust by
not chasing off to Tokyo with the other girls to spy on him. And yet,
no matter what, Ryoko is always there for Tenchi when the chips are
down. He never spoke a truer word than the words he spoke at the end of
Tenchi Forever. Ryoko is someone he can count on...and he knows it
better than anyone. Even though false shadows come to try and spirit
him away in the forms of Haruna, Mayuka and Sakuya, none of them ever
manage to fully come between him and Ryoko in the end. Whether you see
their bond as eternal love or just the forging of a very special
partnership, there is no doubt that Tenchi and Ryoko are a team not to
be messed with!
Basically,
there is no version of the Tenchi story which could not result in a
Ryoko/Tenchi pairing. That's not to say that automatically in every
show she will wind up with him...just that there is an argument for it
in each version of the canon! Ryoko's intense loyalty and courage where
he is concerned often offsets her more embarrassing and pushy
behaviour. And it's pretty much a foregone conclusion that - at the
very least - he is meant to choose her in the Universe series. I'm
completely serious - if you really properly watch the closing credits
to TMIL2, it's pretty clear who the finger is being pointed at!!